“Black Panther’ Is Not the Movie We Deserve”; -Edward Mendoza

In the article ‘Black Panther’ Is Not the Movie We Deserve’, the author discusses the movie Black Panther and gives his own take on the ideals in the movie and connects the movie to the African american experience in america. In the article, he discusses how the movie at first looks like a movie supporting black power and the rights for African Americans, but he argues that when you dig deeper, the movie in actuality vilifies African Americans and portrays them as villains.

However, what I find interesting are two points that he brings up. One was that he criticizes the role of the white CIA agent in the movie and the other point was when he talked about killmonger being treated unfairly by the movie compared to others like the CIA agent. To the first point, I completely disagree because the CIA agent was more of a side-kick to the main cast and only had two heroic scenes in the movie, which was taking a bullet for Zuri and shooting down the gunships before they left Wakanda. Additionally, he wasn’t really central to the main story line of the conflict between T’challa and Killmongerer and if the issue is that the CIA agent is white, that is very discriminatory. To the second point, the vilification of Killmongerer makes perfect sense, as he not only killed many innocents along the way to his rise to the Wakandan throne, but he additionally wanted to kill millions and millions of people in a race war as a way to “liberate blacks from suffering around the world”, which is very much a bad thing. Additionally, his death in the end makes perfect sense when it comes to his character, as throughout his life, he was radicalized by his father’s ideas and opinions on the “colonizers” and throughout his life, he was so blinded by hate that he was willing to do anything to achieve his radicalized goal of getting back at the “oppressors”, not for equality or justice or anything, just pure revenge.


Comments ( 2 )

  1. Ruben Genao
    I think you did a really good job on your analysis considering you totally altered my stance on this. Before reading I had a completely different stance since I was trusting what LeBron was saying since I didn't watch the movie but after reading this analysis I realize that the CIA guy isn't the real hero at the end and that the vilification makes perfect sense since he wanted to start a genocide on white people around the world. These intentions could be comparable with Hitler's intention with the Holocaust, just because Killmonger had "good intentions" and is black doesn't mean what he was doing was right, his actions were more revengeful after all.
  2. Maximo Martinez Grullon
    Even though I really liked your opinion on Lebron's article/points, one thing I would recommend to improve, would be to add more of his points the he discussed through the article, since you only made a little summary of what was about plus 2 of the points, and how you disagree with them, instead of adding more and explaining better. But as mentioned before, I liked your opinion on how the CIA agent wasn't much of a main hero protagonist as Lebron makes it seem, and how is kind off discriminatory for there to be an issue with the CIA agent just because he is white. And I also liked when you explained how having killmonger as the villian would make sense since his idea of "liberation" for black people, wouldn't be something that heroic to do, but instead evil.

Skip to toolbar